ElBaradei meets Sharon: Israel holds fast to 'ambiguity' policy

09 Jul, 2004

Israel held fast to its policy of ambiguity about whether it has nuclear weapons and its refusal to sign the nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty as UN nuclear chief Mohamed ElBaradei concluded a visit Thursday.
International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) chief ElBaradei had come to Israel Tuesday urging the Jewish state to "clarify" whether it has nuclear weapons and to join the non-proliferation regime which his agency is mandated to verify.
But speaking after ElBaradei met with Israeli Prime Minister Ariel Sharon, a senior Israeli nuclear official said there would be no change in the government's longstanding "strategic ambiguity" policy.
"For now, we see no reason, justification or requirement to change it," the official with Israel's Atomic Energy Commission told reporters, referring to the policy of neither confirming nor denying Israel's nuclear weapons capability.
Most foreign experts believe Israel possesses a nuclear arsenal of up to 200 warheads.
ElBaradei was also campaigning to get Israel to sign on to his plan to make the Middle East a nuclear weapons-free zone.
ElBaradei said Sharon had "affirmed to me that Israel's policy continues to be that, in the context of peace in the Middle East, Israel would be looking favourably to the establishment of" such a zone.
"This is not a new policy, but affirming that policy at the level of the prime minister, I find that to be a quite welcome development and a positive development," he said.
But Sharon did not set a time-frame for Israel to back off on its refusal to discuss such security issues while it is still facing attacks from Palestinian groups and hostility from Iran, ElBaradei said.
The UN nuclear chief said "a dialogue on security issues could be envisaged as part of the roadmap which has, as phase two, a discussion of arms control issues in an arms control subcommittee to be established under the roadmap."
He said this was "a good vision ... and I hope we can continue to work to transfer this vision into concrete steps."
The so-called roadmap for peace between Israel and Palestinians is a blueprint that was drafted last year by the United States, European Union, the United Nations and Russia.
It calls for an end to the violence and the creation of a Palestinian state living alongside a secure Israel by 2005 but has made next to no progress to date.
Israeli officials had made clear to ElBaradei their fears about the atomic program in Iran, which has been under investigation by the IAEA since February 2003 for allegedly hiding a secret weapons program, something Tehran denies.
"Israel has its own threat perception which it believes is unique," as the country believes "it is the only state (in the region) that faces an existential threat", IAEA spokesman Mark Gwozdecky told reporters Wednesday after ElBaradei met Israel Atomic Energy Commission chief Gideon Franck.
The Israeli official said that while there had been positive signs in parts of the region, following Libya's renunciation of weapons of mass destruction, the regime in Tehran "is going in the opposite direction and shaking lose" of commitments it had given to both the IAEA and the European Union.
In a bid to illustrate the "unique" nature of Israel's position, ElBaradei was taken Wednesday on a flight over the country by a senior military official that skirted the borders with Lebanon and Syria, both still technically at war with Israel.
A senior diplomat who asked not to be named said ElBaradei was shown the vulnerability of Israel where planes can fly from "one border to another in three-and-a-half minutes".
Meanwhile, ElBaradei said that while Israel rejected joining the NPT, officials had told him the Jewish state was ready to sign an agreement on export controls on nuclear technology sales.

Read Comments