This is apropos two back-to-back letters to Editor by this writer carried by the newspaper on Monday and yesterday. Domestically, issues like healthcare, reproductive rights, and economic stability also shape the community’s preferences.
Harris’s stance on healthcare and social justice resonates with younger, progressive Pakistani Americans, while Trump’s economic policies attract some within the diaspora who favor conservative fiscal approaches. Donald Trump’s policy of directly negotiating with the Afghan Taliban aimed to end US involvement in Afghanistan, culminating in the 2020 Doha Agreement.
The US bypassed the Afghan government and engaged the Taliban as the primary power brokers, offering legitimacy in exchange for assurances against terrorism. This approach prioritized US withdrawal and left Afghanistan’s future governance to internal actors.
The strategy marked a shift from military engagement to diplomatic resolution, with the ultimate goal of exiting a long, costly conflict.
In contrast, Pakistan’s policy towards the Tehreek-e-Taliban Pakistan (TTP) is focused on internal security, dealing with a group that threatens the state’s sovereignty.
Pakistan has used a mix of military operations and occasional peace talks, but these negotiations have not led to long-term stability. Unlike the Afghan Taliban, the TTP is a domestic insurgency ideologically opposed to Pakistan’s governance model.
While military campaigns have weakened the TTP at times, the group continues to pose significant challenges, highlighting the more adversarial nature of Pakistan’s approach compared to Trump’s diplomatic efforts with the Afghan Taliban.
The Pakistani-American community’s views on the upcoming U.S. election reflect both national and personal concerns.
The majority leans towards Harris as the more favourable candidate. Key reasons include her support for immigration reform, which aligns with the needs of Pakistani expatriates, and her more predictable foreign policy approach, particularly towards South Asia.
Harris’s stance on healthcare, social justice, and her potential to balance U.S.-India relations also resonate with younger and progressive members of the diaspora.
In contrast, Trump’s restrictive immigration policies, alignment with India, and his administration’s confrontational stance on China-Pakistan relations have left many in the community wary of a second Trump term.
Qamar Bashir
Copyright Business Recorder, 2024