Britain's second-highest court ruled Monday that soldiers at war are covered by European human rights law, a decision that could compel the military to give troops on the battlefield better equipment and medical care. The case centered on the death of a British soldier, Pvt Jason Smith, 32, who died of heat-stroke while serving in Iraq in 2003.
An inquiry found that the military failed to recognise and take appropriate steps to address the difficulty Smith had adjusting to Iraq's climate. The court upheld an earlier ruling stating that British soldiers serving in military operations are protected by European human rights laws that enshrine the right to life.
Sending soldiers into conflict with inadequate equipment could violate that right, the court said. Smith's mother, Catherine, said she hoped the ruling would prevent similar deaths. ``This victory is not for me, nothing can bring Jason back, but it is for all those brave men and women who are still risking their lives in our name,' she said.
The finding that troops are subject to human rights law wherever they are could have broad implications for Britain's military, which has around 8,000 troops serving in Afghanistan alone. The ministry has already been sued by some families who claim inadequate equipment contributed to the deaths of relatives in Afghanistan and Iraq.
Much of the recent criticism over equipment has been levelled at a type of spy plane that has sparked safety fears and patrol vehicles that have not withstood roadside bombs. The military accepted that human rights laws were applicable in Smith's case, since he died at a medical facility on a British military base.
But the Ministry of Defence argued it should not be required to apply human rights laws in all situations _ such as when soldiers are involved in a battle. The military has said that in the heat of battle, it is impossible to stop and ponder the intricacies of human rights law and that it might cause commanders to hesitate _ leading to a further loss of life.
Comments
Comments are closed.