Switzerland, Austria and Luxembourg offered to relax strict bank secrecy in some tax evasion cases on Friday in a response to a global crackdown on tax havens that is rattling the offshore banking industry. The three countries made the concessions ahead of a meeting starting on Friday of finance ministers from the G20 group of developed and emerging countries due to discuss tax havens, and after similar moves by Andorra and Liechtenstein on Thursday.
-- Austria, Switzerland, Luxembourg agree to OECD tax rules
-- Exchange of tax information on case-by-case basis only
-- Moves comes ahead of G20 meeting to discuss tax havens
-- European Commission gives cautious welcome to measures
All were on a list handed to the G20 this week by the Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD) of financial centres where it deems bank secrecy rules as undesirable. British Prime Minister Gordon Brown, who is chairing a G20 summit in April, welcomed the Swiss moves and said he hoped this was the beginning of the end for tax havens. "The G20 summit in London next month is an opportunity for global agreement on the further actions we need to take to clean up the global financial system," Brown said.
Switzerland, Austria and Luxembourg said on Friday they would abide by OECD rules by co-operating on sharing information about savers with other countries on a case-by-case basis, but not automatically, as many countries want. "The decision will permit the exchange of information with other countries in individual cases where a specific and justified request has been made," the Swiss government said.
Critically, Switzerland will now cooperate in cases of suspected tax evasion, at least once double taxation agreements are renegotiated with other countries, which could take time. It also said it could seek an amnesty for existing clients. Previously, the worlds biggest offshore centre would only cooperate with foreign authorities when they could prove outright tax fraud, which has hindered US access to client data of Switzerlands biggest bank UBS in a tax probe.
Swiss Finance Minister Hans-Rudolf Merz, who also holds the rotating presidency, said Switzerland was acting now because being put on a blacklist, possibly resulting in sanctions, would have hurt the economy. The OECD blacklist currently only includes Liechtenstein, Andorra and Monaco, but France and Germany have been pushing for others, including Switzerland, to be added.
The tax debate is crucial for the wealth management industry, which manages an estimated $7 trillion of assets out of offshore centres around the globe, of which about $2 trillion is held in Switzerland and about $1 trillion in Luxembourg. Merz said it was hard to say whether Fridays moves would prompt an outflow of money, noting that other tax havens like its rising Asian rivals Singapore and Hong Kong have also adopted the OECDs rules recently. All three countries insisted that the move would not lead to "fishing expeditions" by other states for client data and said their banking secrecy rules would be otherwise upheld.
"It is not an open door policy. It is an easing of access to information in respect to tax crime," Merz said. Switzerland has accused the United States of being on a "fishing expedition" by pursuing a civil case against UBS to try to access details of 52,000 clients, even after the Swiss bank paid $780 million to avert related US criminal charges.
In a separate statement on Friday, the Swiss government said it would instruct a US law firm to defend the countrys position in the civil case against UBS. The right-wing Swiss Peoples Party said the government had betrayed citizens and bank customers with its concessions. "With todays decision the government is sacrificing a centuries-old principle of protecting citizens," it said in a statement.
The moves by Austria and Luxembourg, both European Union members, may not be enough to satisfy fellow bloc member states like Germany, which has been vocal in the fight against tax havens since it obtained bank data of citizens suspected of parking money in Liechtenstein last year. The European Commission has proposed that no EU state can hide behind bank secrecy and all must give details about accounts upon request. All EU tax measures require unanimity and Luxembourg signalled a willingness to wield its veto. Luxembourgs Treasury and Budget Minister Luc Frieden said the OECD framework for case-by-case information exchange should be the only principles applied in the EU and the Commission gave a guarded welcome to Fridays announcements. "All steps towards more transparency and exchange of information are welcome. We hope all these declarations will help our proposals on the table to go ahead," the spokeswoman for EU Tax Commissioner Laszlo Kovacs said.
A study for British charity Oxfam on Friday showed that developing countries miss out on tax receipts worth more than the billions of dollars they receive in foreign aid because their own nationals put cash in offshore tax havens. They lose as much as $124 billion in taxes a year, more than their yearly $103 billion in foreign aid, the study showed. Under its deal with the OECD, Austria, a smaller offshore centre with a heavy focus on German clients, will drop its objections to the organisations Model Tax Convention after the OECD clarified that it only expected cooperation with foreign tax authorities if there was probable cause.
On Thursday, the OECD praised recent concessions by Singapore, Hong Kong, Andorra, the Isle of Man, Liechtenstein and the Cayman Islands. "Moves by a number of financial centres over recent weeks have given a welcome boost to efforts to promote transparency and exchange of information on tax matters," OECD Secretary General Angel Gurria said in a statement.
Comments
Comments are closed.