AGL 38.48 Decreased By ▼ -0.08 (-0.21%)
AIRLINK 203.02 Decreased By ▼ -4.75 (-2.29%)
BOP 10.17 Increased By ▲ 0.11 (1.09%)
CNERGY 6.54 Decreased By ▼ -0.54 (-7.63%)
DCL 9.58 Decreased By ▼ -0.41 (-4.1%)
DFML 40.02 Decreased By ▼ -1.12 (-2.72%)
DGKC 98.08 Decreased By ▼ -5.38 (-5.2%)
FCCL 34.96 Decreased By ▼ -1.39 (-3.82%)
FFBL 86.43 Decreased By ▼ -5.16 (-5.63%)
FFL 13.90 Decreased By ▼ -0.70 (-4.79%)
HUBC 131.57 Decreased By ▼ -7.86 (-5.64%)
HUMNL 14.02 Decreased By ▼ -0.08 (-0.57%)
KEL 5.61 Decreased By ▼ -0.36 (-6.03%)
KOSM 7.27 Decreased By ▼ -0.59 (-7.51%)
MLCF 45.59 Decreased By ▼ -1.69 (-3.57%)
NBP 66.38 Decreased By ▼ -7.38 (-10.01%)
OGDC 220.76 Decreased By ▼ -1.90 (-0.85%)
PAEL 38.48 Increased By ▲ 0.37 (0.97%)
PIBTL 8.91 Decreased By ▼ -0.36 (-3.88%)
PPL 197.88 Decreased By ▼ -7.97 (-3.87%)
PRL 39.03 Decreased By ▼ -0.82 (-2.06%)
PTC 25.47 Decreased By ▼ -1.15 (-4.32%)
SEARL 103.05 Decreased By ▼ -7.19 (-6.52%)
TELE 9.02 Decreased By ▼ -0.21 (-2.28%)
TOMCL 36.41 Decreased By ▼ -1.80 (-4.71%)
TPLP 13.75 Decreased By ▼ -0.02 (-0.15%)
TREET 25.12 Decreased By ▼ -1.33 (-5.03%)
TRG 58.04 Decreased By ▼ -2.50 (-4.13%)
UNITY 33.67 Decreased By ▼ -0.47 (-1.38%)
WTL 1.71 Decreased By ▼ -0.17 (-9.04%)
BR100 11,890 Decreased By -408.8 (-3.32%)
BR30 37,357 Decreased By -1520.9 (-3.91%)
KSE100 111,070 Decreased By -3790.4 (-3.3%)
KSE30 34,909 Decreased By -1287 (-3.56%)

It’s very normal, and natural, for milestones like the SLA (Staff-Level Agreement) to be followed by a barrage of ratings agency reports. Foreign investors still rely on their ratings when they commit serious money, after all, despite the humiliation of the 2008 recession.

Hence the finance minister’s zoom meetings with Moody’s and Fitch, regurgitating the same script with the same straight face. Push up our rating a notch because the SLA has come, the executive committee’s nod is coming (late August now?), and we’re ready to implement reforms, privatise SOEs (State Owned Enterprises), expand the tax net, etc.

But why didn’t they talk about the real meat of the reports both agencies released prior to the meetings? Moody’s, for example, appreciated that the EFF (Extended Fund Facility) – all but assured – would “improve Pakistan’s funding prospects”.

But that’s not all it gave its clients – the global investing elite that Pakistan wants to lure to its financial shores. It also warned that the Fund’s “upfront conditions” would grow harder by the tranche, reaching a point where a very unpopular government might struggle to enforce them. It said social tensions, driven by high cost of living, higher taxes and future energy tariff adjustments, could derail the Facility and threaten the government itself.

Fitch went a step further. After duly appreciating the SLA and of course the country’s “funding prospects”, its Business Monitor International (BMI) delved deep into Pakistan’s political economy and presented a 10-year risk profile. Politics aside – Imran staying in jail, surprising judicial sovereignty – it also said very clearly that the present coalition government is “likely to collapse in the event of a sharp increase in violence or a painful economic crisis prompting a widespread crisis movement”. It reckoned the government had about 18 months left in office, and an election would not follow.

The finance minister didn’t bring all this up in the meetings because he’s a veteran banker and knows how this bit alone, regardless of the “funding prospects”, would spook all serious investors. And he was lucky that the agencies didn’t either. Because that would have pulled on the thread that would have unravelled the fancy dress he’s been trying to put on the economy. It would also have exposed his first budget as the one that finally locked the Pakistani economy into a death spiral.

It’s not that a storm is coming and the government cannot see it. It’s much more sinister. It’s that the state created this storm, then nurtured it, allowed it to build, and now prefers to ignore it. Everybody’s worried about social unrest now because the government has piled too much tax burden on a small minority of honest, hard-working, middle- and lower-income class Pakistanis. It’s sinister because the state — regardless of the party in power – always chose to protect the rich and powerful from the tax net.

There was some hope when the banker-turned-finance minister promised to tax real estate, agriculture, wholesale and retail. The country desperately needs additional fiscal space to see the structural reforms of the EFF through, doesn’t it? And failure to meet “upfront conditions” will make IMF cancel the EFF and then Pakistan will default, won’t it? Let’s not forget that the country must pay back debt and interest worth $21bn this fiscal, and another $23 billion next year, while reserves stand at $9.4 billion. And the only thing keeping these “external financing needs” rolling over is an active IMF programme. Should it collapse, so will the economy.

So finally taxing the biggest, most bloated earners of the economy seemed right. That’s what common sense and basic economic theory say, and it’s also desperately needed. Yet nobody has ever done it. Not PPP, despite its slight (in theory) socialist leaning, not PTI even with its “revolution”, and definitely never PML-N.

All of them are stuffed with feudal and industrial barons that really rule this country, no matter who is in power. That is why the finance minister will no doubt walk away from this assignment with an impressive resume and contacts that will land him on fancy boards one day, but neither most Pakistanis nor the Pakistani economy are likely to remember him fondly.

This is the fifth-highest populated country in the world, most of it poor – about half hovering just above or below the poverty line – and also right at the top in terms of illiteracy, according to the UN. Now, even after enduring record inflation and unemployment, this year’s budget will force one of the world’s most cruel, parasitic tax regimes on them, while keeping the richest and most powerful lobby groups comfortably safe from the taxman.

If that does not qualify as criminal, the government is now taking it a step further and refusing to acknowledge the social time bomb that is just months away from exploding.

When hundreds of millions of people start getting bills that their entire incomes cannot cover, and the situation gets incrementally worse, and the big fish continue to eat off the fat of the land, then a social crisis is inevitable.

Yet nobody’s bothered. There’s no talk of a social safety net, no preparation for the rioting that anybody who looks at the country – including ratings agencies headquartered thousands of miles away – can see coming. And instead of making frantic preparations, they’re fishing for ratings upgrades.

Clearly, it’s not just basic economics that is not the Pakistani state’s cup of tea. It’s also too stubborn to learn from history.

Reminds you of a line from a Robert Redford movie.

When did Noah build the Ark?

Before the rain. Before the rain.

Copyright Business Recorder, 2024

Shahab Jafry

The writer can be reached at [email protected]

Comments

Comments are closed.

KU Jul 25, 2024 11:10am
We won our freedom 75 years ago, now we need to win our freedom from our dishonest leaders, a future for our country, perhaps!
thumb_up Recommended (0)
Mumtaz Malik Jul 27, 2024 10:32am
The World Bank announced in its latest development update on Tuesday Pakistan's economy is expected to grow by only 1.8 percent in the current fiscal year ending June 2024,
thumb_up Recommended (0)
Mumtaz Malik Jul 27, 2024 10:33am
Emphasizing the need for structural reforms and warning that 40 percent of the population has slipped below the poverty line.
thumb_up Recommended (0)
Mumtaz Malik Jul 27, 2024 10:39am
The unemployment rate in Pakistan is forecast to 8.00% in 2024. The unemployed people in Pakistan is forecast to 6.61m in 2024. The employment rate in Pakistan is forecasted to 52.19% in 2024.
thumb_up Recommended (0)
Mumtaz Malik Jul 27, 2024 10:39am
The employment rate in Pakistan is forecasted to 52.19% in 2024. The total labor force in Pakistan is forecasted to 82.66m in 2024.
thumb_up Recommended (0)
Mumtaz Malik Jul 27, 2024 10:41am
The article vividly illustrates the disparity in societal treatment between the privileged and the underprivileged, symbolized through the metaphor of "holy cows." It highlights how the wealthy,
thumb_up Recommended (0)
Mumtaz Malik Jul 27, 2024 10:42am
" It highlights how the wealthy and powerful are often shielded from repercussions while the poor bear the brunt of punitive measures, such as burdensome taxes.
thumb_up Recommended (0)
Mumtaz Malik Jul 27, 2024 10:48am
It emphasizes the lack of discernment by nature's forces, like rising water, which indiscriminately affect everyone, regardless of status. However, it underscores a grim reality where the affluent,
thumb_up Recommended (0)
Mumtaz Malik Jul 27, 2024 10:49am
However, it underscores a grim reality where the affluent ("AMEER TREEN") have means to save themselves, while the impoverished are left to suffer the consequences, often unnoticed.
thumb_up Recommended (0)
Mumtaz Malik Jul 27, 2024 10:54am
Remember, again and again, that water is water, whether it comes as rain or the flood of Noah. When it falls, it does not distinguish between the elite and the emperor;
thumb_up Recommended (0)